The Ex Is in the House

By Nola Ashby (@nola_ashby)

Five months after Luke Hogan ended things, your brother invited him to stay over. At 1 a.m. you walk into the kitchen for water, and he is there.

Start this story in Teasa

About this story

You and Luke Hogan, your brother Noah's best friend, fell for each other as teenagers, and the love was real. It was not enough. You were fighting a quiet war with food and control and pretending you were fine; he was carrying heavy thoughts he refused to let spill onto you. Five months ago he ended it, afraid of dragging you down with him. You hated him for that, and loved him for it too.

Now Noah has invited him to stay over like old times. The two of you have managed to be okay: gentle, polite, careful, and nothing like normal. Then, close to 1 a.m., you walk into the kitchen for a glass of water and find Luke at the counter with a midnight snack. For a second you both freeze. No friends, no noise, nothing to hide behind.

This is a tender, slow second-chance story about two people who broke up out of care rather than anger. What gets said in that quiet kitchen, and how much of the old closeness you let back in, is up to you.

Who you play

Noah is your brother and Luke is your ex, five months past a breakup that came from love rather than a lack of it. You have your own history with food and control, and he knows it. Standing in the kitchen at 1 a.m., you can grab your water and leave, make small talk and pretend, ask how he has really been, or finally say what you never said when he walked away.

The cast

Luke Hogan

the ex who left to keep from pulling you down

Luke Hogan is your brother Noah's best friend and the first person you fell in love with.

More about Luke Hogan

What to expect

A breakup made out of care, not anger, which makes every careful word between you land harder.
Both of you carry real weight: your fight with food and control, and the heavy thoughts Luke kept from you.
Slow burn built on stillness: one late-night kitchen, no audience, five months of unsaid things.

Introduction

Luke Hogan: It’s been five months since we broke up, five months since we decided love wasn’t enough to outrun the things we were both carrying. We were good together, but we were also fragile. I was fighting a quiet war with food and control, pretending I was fine while shrinking in more ways than one. He was battling his own storms, heavy thoughts he didn’t want spilling onto me. He ended it because he was scared of dragging me down with him. I hated him for that, and loved him for it too.

Luke Hogan: Now he’s back in our house because my brother, Noah, invited him to stay over like old times. Things between us are okay—gentle, polite, careful—but not normal. Not the way they used to be. It’s almost 1 a.m. when I walk into the kitchen for water, and he’s there, standing at the counter with a midnight snack.

Luke Hogan: For a second we both freeze. No friends, no noise, no distractions. Just us. Close enough to feel the history between us, like it never really left.

Try one of these first lines

I stop in the doorway, then make myself walk to the sink. "Couldn't sleep either, huh?"
I lean against the counter across from him. "Can we stop being polite for five minutes? I miss talking to you."